Sponsored

Question about real battery capacity, charging to “100%” (notice the quotes)

Its PJ Bia

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2023
Threads
4
Messages
276
Reaction score
278
Location
Maine
Vehicles
F150 Lightning PRO
I charge to 90% during the week, the once every couple of months I will charge to 100% to rebalance the cells.
Sponsored

 

Adventureboy

Well-known member
First Name
Jonathan
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Threads
1
Messages
666
Reaction score
632
Location
Ontario
Vehicles
2023 F150 Lightning Lariat
I literally went from 100% to 0% just a week and a half ago. Running out did not cause irreparable harm, there’s a reserve and a buffer but not to the tune of 148kW.
Charging to 100% or depleting to 0% won't kill your battery. Doing it regularly will age them faster.

Ford has thought this through and will not let you use the buffer. It would be too hard on the batteries. If you ran the cells truly down to 0% including buffer, you very likely would brick the truck if it sat there for any period. Sitting at true 100% for any period will also bake the batteries, hence why Ford won't let you do that.

Ford recommends something less than 100% because that keeps the cells within better health parameters for longevity. They don't bother with the low end since most folks won't run down to 0%. If you want your cells to last well past the 8 year, 100,000 mile warranty, the normal daily operating range of 90%-10% SOC should get you there with plenty to spare. That is about 85%-15% of the true battery capacity and well within the "Knees" for good battery health.
 

Adventureboy

Well-known member
First Name
Jonathan
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Threads
1
Messages
666
Reaction score
632
Location
Ontario
Vehicles
2023 F150 Lightning Lariat
I charge to 90% during the week, the once every couple of months I will charge to 100% to rebalance the cells.
Rebalancing the cells does not happen often even when you charge to 100%. It has happened once in my 18 months of ownership on my wife's MME and not yet on my 11-month-old Lightning. When the MME did a top balance, the next day I drove 50km before the SOC meter came off 100%. It was an interesting experience. That day I probably could have driven 500km on the 430km MME.
 

SmoothJ

Well-known member
First Name
John
Joined
Dec 22, 2021
Threads
60
Messages
1,060
Reaction score
774
Location
New Jersey
Vehicles
2021 F150 HEV
I only charge to about 90%, however sometimes during a pre-con or remote start it hits 91% but that doesn't happen often. If I drive to work, I only use 12-15%, and then charge it back up again to 90%. I think I only charged it to 100% maybe 20 times, one of which was due to a OTA update and the other was short road trips to PA.

On my wifes Bolt, which we want to trade-in for a Mach-E, we keep it around 88 to 90%. I can't give you an exact number since its based on a slider vs a number. It fine for what it is, but we keep that low to avoid a "possible fire" related to those batteries packs. We still have yet to get a replacement battery, and GM offered $1400 to keep the current battery pack with strings attached.
 

MickeyAO

Well-known member
First Name
Mickey
Joined
Apr 2, 2020
Threads
26
Messages
1,050
Reaction score
2,094
Location
San Antonio Tx
Vehicles
Rapid Red Lightning Lariat ER, Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD
Occupation
Retired Lab Manager of the Energy Storage Technology Center

Sponsored

MickeyAO

Well-known member
First Name
Mickey
Joined
Apr 2, 2020
Threads
26
Messages
1,050
Reaction score
2,094
Location
San Antonio Tx
Vehicles
Rapid Red Lightning Lariat ER, Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD
Occupation
Retired Lab Manager of the Energy Storage Technology Center
Rebalancing the cells does not happen often even when you charge to 100%. It has happened once in my 18 months of ownership on my wife's MME and not yet on my 11-month-old Lightning. When the MME did a top balance, the next day I drove 50km before the SOC meter came off 100%. It was an interesting experience. That day I probably could have driven 500km on the 430km MME.
Rebalancing happens any time the polarization curve dips below the average charge/discharge time constant learned by the BMS. This may mean spending more than 8-12 hours of just resting.

As an example, during our BOL (Beginning of Life) test, I use a standard or manufacturer recommended cycle, until the cells stop gaining capacity (yes, new cells will gain capacity when initially exercised) and then spend 24 hours at rest so we can find the actual discharge polarization time constant. Then charge the cell and spend 24 hours at rest to find the charge polarization time constant. discharge time constant is typically anywhere from 3 minutes (LTO) to 8 hours (LMO). Charge time constants are typical double of the discharge.

I should have a good idea of the SKE805A time constants next month (but I won't be able to directly tell you what they are)
 

Jim Lewis

Well-known member
First Name
Jim
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Threads
41
Messages
822
Reaction score
689
Location
San Antonio, TX
Vehicles
Honda Accord 2017; 2023 Lariat ER
Occupation
Retired
Rebalancing happens any time the polarization curve dips below the average charge/discharge time constant learned by the BMS. This may mean spending more than 8-12 hours of just resting.
Am I likely to have any cell rebalancing problems if I never charge above 80% but often let my truck sit for days just plugged in, not charging, at 50% charge? And, since I've never charged to 90% or 100%, will I be missing some capacity achieved by cycling new cells? According to actually trip experience and to GOM estimates, I am achieving the Lariat EPA range estimates in spite of my above practices, so I'm a happy camper, mainly interested achieving the maximum battery lifespan with retained performance. Based on my experience so far and my ignorant interpretation of your post that I'm referencing, it seems like I should be doing OK.
 

RonTCat

Well-known member
First Name
Ron
Joined
Jun 30, 2021
Threads
1
Messages
130
Reaction score
160
Location
USA
Vehicles
Mach-E
I really don't want to, but I do have to refute the 90% AC vs DC is no different. There is a world of difference based on the current levels used.

@PreservedSwine if you want to know how to make the cells last virtually forever, find the guy that runs the Energy Storage Technology Center, read all his post of 12 years of hands on testing and data. Should take a couple of hours to get through them all.

BTW, I do not follow his advice on acceleration, but I do on SOC levels.

I do not disagree with your statements.

My point is if the poster has his truck 7 years from now, and charges to 100% once in a while, then the remaining battery "% of new capacity" might be 91%, instead of the 92% percent he would have had if he only went to 80% every time or only topped it at Level 2. Functionally, the poster will not see a tangible difference in the performance of the vehicle or battery.
 

Jim Lewis

Well-known member
First Name
Jim
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Threads
41
Messages
822
Reaction score
689
Location
San Antonio, TX
Vehicles
Honda Accord 2017; 2023 Lariat ER
Occupation
Retired
Just happened to watch Tom Moloughney's State of Charge test of a 2019 Tesla Model 3 that has >100,000 miles on it in four years. In his 70 mph range test, he finds that the vehicle still has 90% of its usable battery capacity. The vehicle had been charged ~75% on DC fast chargers, 25% on AC, occasionally charged to 100% available capacity but then used right away and not allowed to sit at full charge. He found the vehicle consumed 66 kWh in his test vs. 73 kWh of usable capacity in a new Model 3.

At the following time points in his video, he discusses capacity and good battery care habits. Note: this website does not correctly handle the 2nd YouTube timepoint in Moloughney's video. I'll try putting the link in a 2nd independent post to see if that works better.

FIRST TIME POINT (about 14:08 in):
 
Last edited:

Sponsored

TheWoo

Well-known member
Joined
May 20, 2021
Threads
0
Messages
280
Reaction score
466
Location
Manhattan, KS
Vehicles
2023 Lightning Platinum, 2024 Rivian R1T
There is all kinds of miss information and myths about EV Batteries...

Talk to much on your phone and constantly using Apps your battery will go down fast.
One of the myths is that using your phone will have any appreciable impact on efficiency.

My 4400 mAh phone battery is about 16 watt hours, or 0.01% of my truck's usable capacity. Not 1%, 0.01%. Talking on your phone all day long won't have that much impact even taking running the speakers and microphone into account.

I just don't like giving people the impression that they should worry about things like charging their phone or running a laptop. I could run a TV off my pro-power all afternoon and not have much impact at all.

Cabin heater? Now that takes some serious power. Even the A/C isn't that big a power draw in the grand scheme.
 

Jim Lewis

Well-known member
First Name
Jim
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Threads
41
Messages
822
Reaction score
689
Location
San Antonio, TX
Vehicles
Honda Accord 2017; 2023 Lariat ER
Occupation
Retired
Note: this website does not correctly handle the 2nd YouTube timepoint in Moloughney's video. I'll try putting the link in a 2nd independent post to see if that works better.
I couldn't get the second timepoint in Moloughney's YouTube video to play correctly by adding it to my previous post. So here it is by itself in hopes the video starts at the point intended. Perhaps some sort of caching issue I don't understand.

SECOND TIME POINT (about 21:03 in):


P.S. For anyone else with similar problems, pasting the link https: // www.youtube. com/watch?v=EnpKtyrPPKw&t=21m03s with minutes and seconds seems to work better in terms of this website storing the correct time in its database, even though both the above link and the following link https: // www.youtube. com/watch?v=EnpKtyrPPKw&t=1263s result in the text [ MEDIA=youtube]EnpKtyrPPKw:1263[/MEDIA ] being put in the posted text.
 
Last edited:

Jseis

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 22, 2023
Threads
21
Messages
359
Reaction score
540
Location
SW Wa
Vehicles
July 2021 SR MME, July 2023, Lightning Lariat
Does anyone know for sure?
Once upon a time I had a ‘62 VW Bug. It had a 10 gallon tank. Would go forever on a fill up. One day I ran the needle below reserve. Pulled into the gas station. Put 10 gallons in it (to a couple of inches below the fill tube).

I sensed I’d entered a space-time portal where only String Theory and Schrödinger's Cat knew WTF was going on. The LT exhibits the same behavior.
 

John Becker

Well-known member
First Name
John
Joined
Feb 17, 2023
Threads
11
Messages
235
Reaction score
173
Location
Cincinnati
Vehicles
2023 F150 Light'g Lariat SR, '18 Audi S5 Cabriolet
Is it true that 50% SOC is ideal?
If so, then keeping the SOC between, say, 60% - 40% is better than, say, 80% - 20%?
Or am I over-thinking this (again)?
Regardless, what are the ideal SOC high and low points?
 
OP
OP

PreservedSwine

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 5, 2023
Threads
25
Messages
312
Reaction score
371
Location
Fort Myers
Vehicles
2023 Lightning
I suspect the battery has, in reality, a substantially higher capacity than 98KW.
Keeping SOC in the middle is good- but the difference between 20-80 and 40-60 isn’t as great as it sounds because of this.
As someone once said, the truck should be working for you, not the other way around.
enjoy!
Sponsored

 
 





Top