Shifter backorder

[tnugentfl]

Really? If you'll discover freight, it's yours

Sponsored

 

[Stevenhj]

I’ve already bought the knob and the mounting fixture which are ready to install when needed.

 

[farmtruck]

And you’ve had no issues with auto hold or anything else? There are quite a few that seem to have issues with the Mach-e shifter. I just bought a new shifter for the escape as many have said it does not throw any codes or issues.

It has worked beautifully for me. Auto hold works fine. The only new thing with I have experienced is it now will apply the park brake if you open the door or turn off power when not in park.

 

[astrand1]

It has worked beautifully for me. Auto hold works fine. The only new thing with I have experienced is it now will apply the park brake if you open the door or turn off power when not in park.

Copy that. Mine does that now with the original shifter. If I open door or turn off power same thing park brake applies.

 

[tls]

OK. To select the travel direction on an EV requires only a simple electrical signal. The bulky mechanical contraption on our trucks is overly complex and is prone to failure. That’s why it sucks and some are replacing it with something much more simple.

They're going for controls that have the look and feel of traditional ICE controls to avoid excess cognitive load for drivers whose first car wasn't a Lightning. I appreciate this - the first time I tried to put my 2015 Model S into neutral for a car wash, my head just about exploded, never mind that lovely company's awesome midwinter UI update that buried the defroster controls 3 layers deep in menus.

IF IT WORKED RELIABLY I would greatly prefer the Lightning shifter to the rotary knob. We have a 24 Mach E with the knob and I always feel like I have to look at it to confirm its position (Headlight switch on these cars is the same way, a "fake mechanical" knob whose actual position is meaningless. Hate that even more). But it is clearly not reliable.

If I had my druthers it'd be Pushmatic 2025! Simple physical buttons, one per gear. No need to look down to hit them and nothing sticking up to interfere with the work surface.

The fake column-shifter on the other Mach E in our stable (2025 GT) is nice too.

 

[Mike G]

How is that rotary shift knob working out for folks; any issues or warranty denials for swapping it out?

I love mine. I'm using the one from a '21/'22 Bronco Sport with the rubberized knob. No issues.

 

[Robert1380]

I love mine. I'm using the one from a '21/'22 Bronco Sport with the rubberized knob. No issues.

I have the parts on order so I’m gonna give it a shot.

 

[Mike G]

I swapped to a rotary knob. It is a less intuitive than the lever, but sure freed up space on the console. If I don't shift to park before opening the door or depowering the vehicle, it will set the park brake and I have to manually release it to move again. I general, I do like it due to the freed up space on the console.
As far as warranty, mine is dealer installed using a new module from a Bronco Sport and a tub from Manion Makes.

Dude! Your dealer service department did the switch for you? How cool is that!

 

[Mike G]

Nice! Which part number did you get for the rotary shifter?

This may be helpful.

In fact that whole thread is worth a read.

 

[Mike G]

I would NOT go with any version that came on a Mach-E. That's the one that seems to cause issues. From what I've read and experienced, you want the version that came on a '21/'22 Bronco Sport, or Escape, (and possibly the Maverick? I think somebody reported using one of those). Newer versions '23/'24 may also work as well but I haven't seen anything written about those.

I believe all of these have the motorized knob that will actually rotate the selector from D to P when you open the driver's door, versus simply changing the LED from D to P without the knob moving.

 

[farmtruck]

I kind of like the no motor MachE knob. One less failure mode.
If the others don't set the park brake if you open the door in gear, it would be a plus for them.

 

[Mike G]

I kind of like the no motor MachE knob. One less failure mode.
If the others don't set the park brake if you open the door in gear, it would be a plus for them.

But does it throw DTCs? I thought somebody said that the Mach-E version threw DTCs all the time. That's why I went with the Bronco Sport version (same as Escape).

 

[farmtruck]

But does it throw DTCs? I thought somebody said that the Mach-E version threw DTCs all the time. That's why I went with the Bronco Sport version (same as Escape).

It coded on the door module when I first powered up. Cleared them. None since.

 

[ko_hhr]

I have the shift driver moved from my lightning. I will sell inexpensively.

Dm sent

 

[mgmessner89]

Same boat here. I filed for Buyback recently. Since I’ve owned the truck starting 7/18 of last year I’m coming up on 2.5 months in the shop. First shifter took 2 weeks. Battery module 7 took 3.5 weeks and now my second shifter replacement and it’s been at the shop for going on 30 days. It sucks because I love to Azure Gray but I’m just done with this truck.

Sponsored